Since
Ubuntu integrated
DejaDup as a default backup tool for users' data, I've stopped using
BackupMonitor, my miniature framework for personal backups.
Just to sum things up, and also because
BackupMonitor still has some features that IMHO are missing to
DejaDup, here is a quick comparison of both applications.
The common stuff first,
DejaDup and
BackupMonitor are both aimed at making copies of personal data, regularly.
DejaDup is quite a polished and solid applications:
- it handles several backup destinations (local or in the cloud)
- it uses the duplicity backup tool (itself built on rsync)
- it starts the backup quasi-transparently and doesn't need much user attention
- it makes it possible to restore backed up files with a simple click ((I happily haven't had to test this functionality so far))
- as it is configured in Ubuntu it copies everything in the home folder (except trash and custom selections of folders)
BackupMonitor is a lot more basic:
- it handles only one local destination (usually a symbolic link pointing at a folder on an external hard drive)
- it uses rsync directly and without much subtleties
- it warns the user when a backup is needed and guide her through important steps (like plugging the external hard drive, reporting errors etc)
- it doesn't help very much in restoring files, and just make sure that the latest backup gathers in a same folder all the files that can "just" be copied
- by default it backs up the "conventional" directories recognized by the freedesktop standards Documents, Videos, Music, Images
The only trick that gives
BackupMonitor a little advantage IMHO (and not counting that this is one of my pet projects ;) ), is that the backup is split into atomic steps (or "items").
For instance the
Documents folder is an item (and its complete backup is a "step") and so is the
Videos folder, which makes it easy to display the progress of the backup step by step ("your
Documents have been backed up", then "your
Videos have been backed up" etc).
And this is mostly interesting because it makes it possible to define "custom" items. The basic examples, provided with the latest release, are the backups of the databases of several applications (Thunderbird, Miro etc) made by exporting their data as flat regular files in temporary folders that can then be backed up with
BackupMonitor's internal rsync routine.
Of course Ubuntu's setting of
DejaDup eradicates the uses for such features by backing up the full content of my home folder. However I still kinda miss the ability to add some "custom backup steps".
Anyway, and since we're at it, if you use
DejaDup on Ubuntu, you may be interested in adding space consuming useless stuff like
~/.cache to the exclusion list of
DejaDup ((and if we're at the same level of paranoia you'll do the same for sensible privacy related data like
~/.ssh)) !
